Luca Malagoli

Mrs. Quickly Feeling for Law? The Vermont Justice of the Peace and the «legally relevant categories»

  • Abstract

Informations and abstract

Keywords: Holmes; Legal Categories; Legal Realism; Prediction; Particularity.

The article analyzes (and criticizes) the interpretation of a well-known page of Holmes's "The Path of the Law" put forward by Frederick Schauer in his remarkable book "Thinking like a Lawyer". As I try to point out, indeed, Schauer's attempt to interpret the tone of mockery displayed by Holmes in telling the famous story of the Vermont Justice of the Peace as an evident symptom of his scarcely Realistic, out-of-date conception of relevant legal categories is both ungenerous and misleading. Moreover, if better understood, Holmes's thinking about this crucial topic, far from being a disappointing remnant of legal classicism, shows his seminal contribution to the rising of the American legal Realism.

Trova nel catalogo di Worldcat

Article first page

Article first page