Abstract

In this paper, we raise a few questions for Bartosz Brozek, Monica Bucciarelli and Philip Johnson-Laird. The questions we ask to Bucciarelli and Johnson-Laird concern the nature of the "sense of correctness" which is at the heart of our normative judgments and reasoning, and the status of the laws of logic relating to mental models. Our questions to Broz.ek concern the distinction he traces between rudimentary and abstract rules, the role of language in normative behaviour, and the role of mental simulation in the understanding of abstract rules.